I have had two CATOs of E12s prior this service bulletin. And two destroyed rockets. These were all on older lot numbers than covered in the service bulletin.
If you look at the MESS database, you'll see that the E12 tops the list of motor failures by a wide margin: https://www.motorcato.org/latest#most
It's not a motor I would fly in a rocket I care about. You can't depend on the older lot numbers being reliable.
While I'm glad Estes is finally accepting that they have a problem, it's disappointing that it took over 10 years of well above average MESS reports to finally take minimal action. Offering store credit isn't good payment for my destroyed rockets.